A quote usually shows the install price and maybe the first service visit. That number tells you what it costs to start, not what it costs to keep the system running. Two systems with similar prices can have very different running costs, and the gap often shows up in consumables and upkeep rather than the equipment itself.

List the recurring items

Write down every cost that repeats while you own the system:

  • Consumables such as salt, filter cartridges, UV lamps and sleeves, or membranes, depending on the type of system.
  • Media or resin replacement, and when it is expected to be needed based on the stated life.
  • Electricity used by the unit, if it has a pump, control head or lamp.
  • Water sent to drain during regeneration, backwash or flushing, which adds to your water bill.
  • Service visits, and exactly what each visit includes and excludes.
  • Periodic testing, if the system's performance needs to be checked.

Ask each provider for the same answers in writing

Ask for the consumables schedule, the replacement interval for each part, the expected life stated for the equipment, the electrical rating, and an estimate of drain water use. A provider who cannot give these figures, or gives them only verbally, has not made the comparison easy for you.

Use one usage assumption for both

Convert each recurring cost into a per-year figure, and use the same household usage assumption for every quote. Write that assumption down, including the number of people in the home and the water use you expect. If one provider assumes a different usage pattern, rework their figures so the comparison is fair.

Treat the stated life as a claim to confirm

A stated life is the provider's estimate, not a guarantee. Ask what the life depends on, such as water conditions, maintenance and usage, and ask what the warranty covers if the part fails early. Then ask how the replacement would be priced when the time comes, since that cost belongs in the total.

If you are shopping in the St. Louis area, the local ratings page lists the providers we evaluated, which can help you build the list of questions before you request quotes: St. Louis Water Treatment Ratings: 6 Providers Evaluated.

Decide on the total, not the first line

Once every recurring item is written down on the same basis, add the per-year figures and compare them against the upfront price. The lower invoice is only the better choice if its running costs are not higher, and the total is what you will actually pay over the years you own the system.