A rotten egg smell is unpleasant, and most people assume it comes from the well or the city supply. Before you start testing the source, compare the hot and cold taps. Where the smell lives tells you where to look first.

Compare hot and cold

Run the cold tap for a minute and smell the water, then do the same at the hot tap. If the cold water smells too, the source, the treatment equipment, or the supply line is a more likely cause. If the smell appears only on the hot side, the water heater is the first suspect. Test each tap separately rather than relying on memory, because smells fade quickly once you move on.

Why the hot side matters

Water heaters hold water at a warm temperature for long periods, which can let certain bacteria grow in the tank and produce sulfur compounds. Some tanks also use a sacrificial anode rod, and a reaction involving that rod can add to the smell. A heater technician can usually check both possibilities. You cannot confirm the cause from the smell alone, so treat the heater as the first place to look rather than the final answer.

Early signs to notice

The earliest clues are a smell that is strongest at the first draw and fades after the tap has run for a while, a smell that returns after the house has sat unused, and a hot tap that smells while the cold tap is clear. Notice also whether the smell appears after the heater has been off or has been set to a different temperature. Any of these suggests the heater, not the well, deserves attention first.

What to check before you call

Look at the heater's age and whether you know when the anode rod was last inspected. Check whether the smell is worse after a period of no use. Make a short note of which taps smell and when, so the technician has something specific to work from. Do not change the thermostat or drain the tank on your own without asking how the process should be done.

Questions for the heater technician

Ask whether they can inspect the anode rod and whether it needs replacing. Ask what a sanitizing or flushing step involves, how long the tank should be left alone during it, and whether you should avoid using the hot water during that time. Ask whether the smell is likely to return and what you should watch for afterward.

When to bring in water testing

If the cold water smells as well, or if the smell persists after the heater has been serviced, ask a water treatment provider to test the supply. A filter or softener will not fix a smell that starts in the heater, and it may not fix one that comes from the source either, so the diagnosis comes before any equipment decision.